By illegal I mean a lot of things It could either be piracy, black market, child pornography, etc.
Well, if I saw an instance serving child sexual-abuse material (CSAM)¹, I would report it to NCMEC and possibly also the ISP where that instance was hosted. I expect that this would lead to it being taken down by the ISP or by law enforcement.
I think a lot of other users would do the same. We might also message our home instance admins and suggest defederating from that instance; but this is secondary.
However, if I saw an instance serving (say) torrent links for pirated movies, I would not feel any need to do anything about it. The copyright industries can pay for their own enforcement.
¹ By “CSAM” I mean material involving the sexual abuse of an actual child; not fictional stories or drawings. Y’all loli/shota manga fans may be perverts but you’re not molesters, and your stuff is not illegal where I live.
defederation is pretty swift around here from what I have seen.
deleted by creator
Nothing is preventing an instance catering to any or all of those from being created, but that instance could be defederated by other instances who don’t want to support that content.
I mean it’s not like there aren’t still governments who’d love to shut shit like that down
what would prevent an instance sith illegal content from spawning and trhiving?
Only a Sith deal in absolutes.
Instances can choose to defederate from other instances for any reason. Think of them like divorced parents: they refuse to talk to each other. Federation is vital to the Fediverse. If most instances end up defederating, the illegal content instance can’t thrive.
It would take a Jedi sysadmin to handle it.
deleted by creator
Groups of defederated instances could then stay federated between each of them. Don’t you guys fear that this could cause at some point a lot of harm to Lemmy’s public image?
If all the instances hosting illegal content federated with each other it would be easier for law enforcement to take them down
This has already been happening with Mastodon for years. It creates a need for instance admins to stay on top of defederating from those instances, and from instances that refuse to defederate from those instances. It doesn’t particularly impact public perception of Mastodon overall.
