Please post one top-level comment per complaint. Then others can reply with ideas or existing GitHub issues that could address that complaint. This helps identify both common complaints and potential solutions.
You can also reply on !polls@reddthat.com to better organize the discussion:
https://reddthat.com/post/5049064
I believe there are a large number of feature requests on Lemmy’s GitHub page, making it difficult for developers to prioritize what’s truly important. I propose creating a quarterly pinned post on Lemmy asking users for complaints and suggestions. This way, developers can better understand the community’s biggest pain points and what to focus on. The goal is to provide constructive feedback so developers can prioritize the most pressing issues.
Please keep discussion productive and focused on specific problems. Avoid vague complaints or feature wishes without justification. Our aim is to give developers clear insights into issues impacting users most.
This has been suggested many times, but we need a way to link comments and posts in an instance-agnostic way. Getting pulled to a new instance when you click a link is very confusing for new users. Another use case that was common on reddit that won’t work without this feature is you can’t have a stickied post with links to other important posts in the community. People will get pulled into the instance that the linker is in, which means people who follow the link will be logged out (unless their account is on the same instance as OP) and won’t be able to interact with the post.
This isn’t a nice-to-have feature. This is a must-have feature.
Until this is officially added, there are browser addons that will automatically convert links to your own home instance.
Yea LemmyLink gives you something to click on, but it gets slow on long pages because it replaces links themselves.
InstanceAssistant you need to right click, but it’s fast. This one also lets you open a post back on your home instance, for if you already ended up somewhere. I use that more than the link conversion because usually I don’t need to comment on the posts so when I do, I click the button to redirect.
They really need to handle them in Lemmy though
Sure, and that’s great to know and remind people. You and I know how to workaround the issue, but the experience is broken for people who don’t. People who are new to lemmy don’t know that they need to install a browser extension. And that’s why this isn’t an acceptable solution. This needs to be a very high priority, and should be the next thing they work on after 0.19 release.
If there is an extension for it, it means that it can be implemented fully client-side.
If it can be implemented client-side, it shouldn’t be implemented server side. It just makes things harder to scale and more expensive to run.
Maybe this could be a feature request on lemmy-ui, but not for lemmy itself.
If anyone wants to track this issue https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy/issues/2987
Thank you very much. You are a gentleman and a scholar.
Doesn’t this already work with proper links? E.g this link works fine for me in a Voyager and my standard mobile browser too: !polls@reddthat.com
That’s a community, not a post or a comment. Try the link to this post.
Oh gotcha, I was working around it without even realizing it by going to the community and finding the post at the top 🤦♂️
I want something similar to multi-reddits. I want to mix and match communities to my hearts desire into one big feed. I also want to combine duplicate communities from different instances to the same feed.
My number one desired feature for Lemmy. It’s all I’m missing from Reddit.
A way to group communities would make my moderating tasks so much easier.
We’ve been asking for something like this from the beginning.
If anyone wants to track this issue
Yes yes yes. This is my #1.
I’m using accounts in different instances as multis for the time being. At least I can have different sets of subscriptions. It’s not ideal, but it’s better than nothing.
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
Repetition. The front page algorithm frequently shows way too many posts from a single community, often in a row. It also tends to show me a lot of duplicated posts that have been reposted to multiple communities.
There needs to be a better mix in the way posts are selected. Popular communities should not be able to dominate the listing with multiple posts. The more posts they get to the front page, the more they should be down-weighted in order to give an equitable mix.
This complaint applies to All, Local, and Subscribed. If you don’t want to change the default algorithm, then perhaps add the new one as an option?
There is a “scaled sort” that will be released in the next version iirc.
I definitely agree with this one. It makes browsing feel very stagnant at times, because unless I go out of my way to view the communities I’ve subscribed to then I don’t really see most of them.
Now we are free of reddit we need to separate NSFW and NSFL. Not sure if allowing both on the same post should be allowed but we defiantly need to have both as options.
And spoilers
Why don’t we just make it Flair’s so it can do whatever is needed now / in the future.
AFAIK the NSFW is actually part of Activity Pub (e.g. its bigger than lemmy).
To fix this, I think Lemmy should adopt a system like hashtags or flairs. This would allow anything, like spoliers, or a market communities adding #sold, etc. The app displaying the posts can choose what to do with them (e.g. filtering out #nsfl)
I think the ideal solution would be content warnings like Mastodon has, maybe these convert to NSFW posts for activityPub but within Lemmy surely they can work the way intended.
The mod tools are too basic and barebones. I’d appreciate if we can get:
- Post approval system for new or low-karma accounts (it can be karma for local communities)
- Reporting system with multiple options (very hard to implement in the fediverse as everyone has different rules) so that the reports are sent to the proper channels. Admins shouldn’t have to deal with community-specific rules (for example, “memes only on mondays”).
- Automoderator (these might already exist? I have not tried them.)
I don’t know if I should split this comment into three or not but they’re some general suggestions to address the complaint of basic mod tools.
Automoderator (these might already exist? I have not tried them.)
awesome lemmy lists a few.
Don’t think there is an automod
deleted by creator
I did say the complaint:
The mod tools are too basic and barebones
I also gave three ideas that are (1) manually done by mods/admins, (2) manually done by users, (3) automated by mods/admins.
On a small subreddit I moderate, we have automod automatically queue posts at a certain age. If your account is less than a day old, your post is hidden for public viewing while the mods manually approve it. We had to deal with a lot of spam bots and this was a good solution for us.
I believe the way the report feature works on Lemmy is that it sends out to the mods of the community and all the admins. It doesn’t work quite well when I don’t know the rules of a community. “No memes on mondays”, is that really something I (as an admin) should be worried about? That’s not my job.
I hope this clears things up.
Proper cross posts
If anyone wants to track this issue https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy/issues/3827
I miss the ability to view all the posts that I upvoted.
You can do a “thumbs up” on github, iirc the developer said last time i talked to him is that this is what they use for prioratization.
Here is the list of the most “thumbs up” issues on github for the “lemmy” repo.
We could always use rysolv (a bounty platform), that can different from “I want this” and “i think it is important enought to risk some of my money for it”.
And for the curious, but ultimately too lazy to click, there is the top 10ish at this moment.
- Support for grouping communities / multi-communities 👍 184
- Post tags 👍 91
- Allow instance migration for communities and users 👍 72
- Instance agnostic links 👍 63
- User Flair Feature 👍 44
- Dynamically subscribe to other instances communities 👍 26
- OAuth (2.0) 👍 25
- Add community privacy oriented settings
https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/u/930215
👍 24
9. Co-hosting communities across instances (e.g. “sharding”) 👍 22
10. Add native support for polls 👍 19
11. Local only community 👍 18
12. No ARM Dockerfile available 👍 18Don’t forget to look at a similar list of ✅ closed issues.
Yeah, this post might be a bit clickbaity, luring people with false expectations. I suppose OP has not spoken a word with the devs, and they won’t look at this thread, nor do they see a need for a poll of some sorts. Or maybe I’m wrong, but the wording is suspiciously vague.
Thanks for pointing out what actually works; GitHub issues and bounties.
Avatar deletions don’t federate. When you delete your avatar on your instance, it doesn’t get deleted across the threadiverse / fediverse.
There needs to be a way to tag posts, similar to Reddit’s flair system but with multiple flairs.
Also related to the aforementioned, a working search by flair system. Searching posts on a subreddit by flair never worked for me.
Would be interesting to make “flairs” federated so u could give a post a flair from a different community/server. Would be very helpful for categorisation of all Lemmy data as a general information source.
Permalinks to comment chains are buggy and need their functionality improved. I spend a lot of my time on Lemmy commenting and conversing with other users. Once a chain exceeds about 8 replies, it becomes increasingly difficult to find the thread with the permalink button from my inbox. This is a problem that some mobile clients have solved, like Mlem, but it should also behave correctly on desktop.
2 feature requests:
Combine posts from different instances into a single item.
Allow filtering or blocking by regex. So I can filter all subs that have a word in them or match a pattern.
deleted by creator
Maybe its just me, but there is one very common thing that happen to me through any firefox (desktop or mobile) and irrespective of any specific lemmy server, and irrespective if I’m authenticated or browsing as public/anonymous.
Lets say I’m looking at the front page of lemmy.world. I’ve reached the bottom of the page (lets call that page #0) and hit the “NEXT” button. The next page loads successfully displaying the next page of items (so now we’re on page #1). I click/tap into an article or comments of one. This loads successfully. When I finish reading, I click/tap the BACK button in the browser. Since I was on Page #1 I would expect to go back to Page #1. Instead I GO BACK TO PAGE #0! So I have to scroll to the bottom of Page #0, hit NEXT again, Page #1 loads successfully. If I were to click/tap into different article or comments, read, and hit BACK in the browser, I would have to repeat the same page #0, scroll to the bottom, hit NEXT to return to Page #1 again.
Any ideas? Is there a different button somewhere in the body of the page I should be clicked a back function instead of using the browser built in BACK button?
You can open the post in a different tab, clicking the middle button or ctrl+click, until they fix this.
Hard to do with a trackpad or phone, (but I can’t remember it happening on my phone.)
This bug is why when I’m casually scrolling I tend to avoid clicking anything that isn’t a meme that can be opened in-line.
For trackpad you can hold Ctrl while you click (or probably cmd on Mac?) to open in a new tab
For the phone have you tried any of the Lemmy apps yet? There’s a bunch of really good ones already
(Your complaint is still a valid bug report, just helping you to work around it until it gets fixed)
I should get a phone app…
I would like an option within settings to get comments sorted by ‘Top’ (or new/hot) when I open any post. Thanks.
This is particularly needed because when you sort by Top manually it reloads the page and requires scrolling through the sometimes very long post body again.
Boost (a Lemmy app) allows this and it is a good feature yeah
I thought boosts were basically “+2 Upvote”. Unless maybe that’s just Kbin’s implementation.
deleted by creator
Boost the Lemmy client, not the feature. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.rubenmayayo.lemmy
Oof, I should do read more gooder. Thanks lol
Finally, confirmation that I’m not dumb and that this is really missing! Seems very odd that something so basic as sort order has been left out of the settings.
I for one am changing the sort order to Top, manually, on Every. Single. Page.
